To achieve a rustic look, start by painting the wood pumpkins in muted, distressed colors like off-white, burnt orange, or dark green. Use sandpaper to distress the edges, giving them a worn, vintage appearance. You can also add accents like twine around the stem, attach burlap leaves, or glue small wooden cutouts for extra texture. Using chalk paint and adding a wax finish gives the pumpkins a matte, aged look perfect for rustic fall décor.